preview

In An Absolute Monarchy

Decent Essays

Document Based Question 4 In an Absolute Monarchy, the Monarch has complete, or absolute, power over his or her people. When faced with such a power one might not know how to deal with it and many people will have many different opinions about the system. During the time of the Holy Roman Empire and other absolute monarchies, the main opinions on the system were that the monarch should have absolute power over his or her people, no person should be faced with that much power, and that the people should be ruled by a group of people rather than one ruler. These opinions and different viewpoints are the same as many people today and are reflected by many of today’s governments. Many people believe that a nation should be ruled by a leader and …show more content…

Bayle St. John is a strong believer of this as well. In The Memoirs of the Duke of Saint-Simon on the Reigns of Louis XIV [r.1643-1715], and the Regency, 1857 John states “The frequent fetes, the private promenades at Versailles, the journeys, were means on which the King seized in order to distinguish or mortify the courtiers, and thus render them more assiduous in pleasing him...Louis XIV took great pains to be well informed of all that passed everywhere; in the public places, in the private houses, in society and familiar intercourse. His spies and tell-tattlers were infinite...all these letters were seen by him alone, and always before everything else... These unknown means ruined an infinite number of people of all classes, who never could discover the cause; often ruined them very unjustly; for the King, once prejudiced, never altered his opinion.” In this excerpt you can tell that John does not believe on having absolute power. This may be because he is not in absolute power, but he does see the effects of this kind of monarchy on the people in which it is reigned over. He sees and understands how Louis XIV was a very intrusive king and used his power unjustly which, according to John, “Ruined an infinite number of people of all classes.” Bayle St. John seemed to share the views of John Dalberg who is known for the famed quote “Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts …show more content…

The Royal commision is against this. In the Report of the Commission of Enquiry into the Conditions of the Peasants of Bohemia, the commission has this to say on the subject of taxing peasants, “Even those nobles who have the best intentions are unable to protect their peasants, because their agents are rough, evil, violent and grasping… The Kingdom of Bohemia is like a statue which is collapsing because its pedestal has been taken away, because all the charges of the Kingdom are born by the peasants who are the sole taxpayers.” What the Royal commision is saying is that not one man can rule an entire kingdom if even his men cannot help to rule portions of it. Also, that in making these small, uncontrollable portions, the ruler is begging for a collapse since the tax collectors of these portions are making it impossible for the peasants to live there. The Royal commision believes that the peasants should be thought of more than the monarch, since they bring in most of the Kingdom’s

Get Access