preview

Comm 101 Tutorial 4A Essay

Decent Essays

Week 9 Tutorial: Ethics of Consumption (Assessed)
Readings:
Shaw et. al. (2013), Chapter 5: The Morality and Ethics of Consumption. Textbook Reading: Why Do We Consume So Much, by Juliet Schor, pp.258-66.
Task for students
Once you have read the textbook chapter and the Reading, answer discussion questions 1, 3- 5 (ignore questions 2 and 6).
Q1. Who is the “we” in the question “Why do we consume so much?” Is Juliet Schor correct that “there is increasingly little that we do which is not a consumption experience”? And that we have become a culture of excessive consumption? Explain your answers.

The “we” in the question “why do we consume so much?” is stands for the majority of Americans those whose basic needs are met, who have …show more content…

Also, the income that people earned determines the level of consumption. The more they earned, the more or luxury goods they are able to purchase.

I do not agree that working long hours encourages people to consume more. I have some working experiences before. After working for the whole day, I felt very tired and I thought money does not come easily, so I would not buy as much as I earned. I would like to save it and buy wait until I think the price of the good I want to buy is acceptable and it is useful.

Q4. Schor refers to the second structural feature that creates too much consumption as “the ecological bias”. What does she mean by this? Do you agree with her that it is serious?

Schor means that people overuse of the ecological resources of the earth, which account for global warming, species extinction, ecosystem depletion, water shortages, deforestation and soil erosion. I absolutely agree with her that overuse of natural capital is serious because the rate of resource use, pollution, and ecological degradation exceeds earth’s absorptive and regenerative capacities. We are already beyond a sustainable relation with earth. If rest of the world lived like the Americans do, need an additional four planets to support this lifestyle.

Q5. Explain why you agree or disagree with Schor’s contention that consumption has become a social competition. How has the old

Get Access